How to Remove A Broken Screw without An Extractor (5 Easy Steps)

A broken screw while twisting or a screw with no head is a common scenario for the DIYers. It’s quite frustrating when you don’t have an extractor or additional kits right at that time. So, knowing how to remove a broken screw without an extractor will take you out in this situation.

To remove the broken screw, insert a flat, wide rubber band between a screwdriver and the screw. Then apply firm but slow pressure to turn the screw. If you’re lucky, the rubber will fill all the gaps induced by the tape and can be removed.

There are other ways to remove a broken screw except using the extractor. Read till the end to find out more about it!

How to Remove A Broken Screw without An Extractor

You may need the ingenuity to remove a broken screw, but it’s pretty easy. There are several methods for removing a broken screw. We will start with the easy method and finish with a rather complex way. 

The methods will vary depending on the circumstances you face and the importance of removing the determined exposed screw. You must know about some necessary tools which are required at home:

  • A Hammer
  • Screwdriver kit
  • Rubber band
  • Needle-nose plier

Step 1: Don’t use the wrong Tools

First and foremost, avoid the skills or tools that cause the screw to strip. It will not permit you to exert superior control over the pressure used on your stripped screw most of the time.

Step 2: Keep a Screwdriver 

You must use a small screwdriver with a massive head. You can even select different screw heads for better control. an Allen-shaped or Torx-shaped screwdriver set can give you the necessary grip to quickly pull your stripped screw. Note that you must move slowly to maintain a large amount of downward pressure and avoid a worsening case.

Step 3: Use the Rubber Band 

A screw can sometimes strip to the point where no other head type will work. You can use the rubber band at this time. It will give you sufficient grip to pull your screw or help to loosen it. 

Place the rubber band between your screw and the screwdriver and then tighten it. Now turn that screw with a solid but slow force. Your rubber band may fill the gap left by that strip at this point.

Step 4: Use Clamp Locking Plier

Although the rubber bands are valuable tools, they will not allow you to remove that screw together. In that case, you’ll need a clamp locking plier to complete the job. Turning your stripped screw back and forth helps remove it altogether.

Step 5: Finish it off 

If none of those mentioned methods work, chiseling your screw head can be an option. Let’s give those stripped areas a little more depth. Therefore, you can compensate for the tension lost during the strip. 

But do so with care and force. You can completely lose your screw if you hammer so hard. As a final resort, this method is suggested.

How to Extract the Small Broken Screw

You will find that removing damaged or broken screws is difficult. However, because there is negligible metal to handle, things can worsen when removing the small broken screws. Using standard-size equipment on undersized metal, on the other hand, is more complex. 

How to Extract the Small Broken Screw

Step 1: Use Vise Grip Plier

Start the procedure by grasping a shaft with a vise grip plier and rotating it from both ways. You might be able to loosen it up by moving forth and back.

Step 2: Apply lubricating Oil

If you don’t want to remove the busted screw right away, implement penetrating oil to the screw’s shaft. The more oil that exudes in, the better it works. With the help of a vise grip plier, try to pull that screw once more.

Step 3: Heat your Screw

Heat your screw with the butane torch. Also, you can heat that screw with the heated steel rod. The objective is to warm your screw without sabotaging the surrounding area. 

Permit some cooling span before skimming your screw with the finger. Then, use the vise grip plier, and remove that broken screw.

Step 4: Make A Large Hole

Drill a massive hole in the screw’s shaft using a more significant drill bit. Create a hole in it until you have only small remnants of that screw left. Finally, use a pointed element to eliminate the remnants.

What are the Quickest ways to extract the stripped screws?

There are some quick and straightforward ways to remove a stripped screw. Let’s have a look at them!

Method 1: Using the Impact Driver

You can use that high-quality bit impact driver to extract the damaged bolt. Using a Phillips or a flathead screwdriver can be an option. 

Place it and pull it after you’ve gathered all of the necessary items. Then clear dust and debris off the head, and check that the bit is pointing in the right direction.

Put on your protection glasses and snugly insert your impact driver into the damaged screw head. You may need to lash the grasping end of your broken screw with a hammer twice. 

After setting the bit firmly embedded in that screw head, you can lose your screw by turning the impact driver head. Now it’s time to remove your screw with a screwdriver or drill.

Method 2: Use Manual Screwdriver Technique

Use this procedure if you can’t remove the damaged screw because the screwdriver slides against the head of the screw. Tap your screwdriver down with a hammer. Then, make sure that it is securely staying stable to the head of the screw.

If the fastener is composed of soft metal, it will give you the additional grip to twist it. To improve your grip on the screw, wrap it with duct tape. Using the screwdriver, insert the material in the spot and try again.

A little flat-headed screwdriver is needed for a Phillips’s head screw. With that screwdriver, you can easily remove the screw.

Method 3: The Rubber Band magic

People who want to know how to remove a damaged bolt can also use this method. The rubber band’s rubbery surface supports the retention of the screwdriver. Any rubber band or tire innertubes will work when it allows the screwdriver to make maximum contact with the damaged screw.

Begin by wrapping the smooth rubber band around the screwdriver’s end. Then push it far enough into the damaged screw’s head to ensure a good fit. Now you can remove the damaged or seized screws. 

If your screw has minor damage, you need a rubber stripe to seal the cracked areas. It may help you to remove the screw

Method 4: Use the Table Knives

This trick is helpful for people who want to unscrew a tight one without any screwdriver. So, you can use a knife to remove that screw with its tip.

However, remember that you need to use a knife for a round-trip. You can remove Phillips screws by using this method.

What are the most effective ways to drill a screw out?

When you don’t have an extractor on your hand, you may drill out the screws. Here are some ways to do it effectively. 

Step 1: Find the correct drill

Don’t rush to drill. You may find a metal drill very well at low speeds and moderate feed rates. Also, it’s safer and won’t break the piece and your wrist if the bit is caught.

Step 2: Start with a tiny bit

Start small to get some depth-first. 1/8-inch is an excellent option to start. Move very slowly to grind out your screw slots. The Phillips head screws will quickly go into the spaces, so work slowly, and you can increase the speed a bit.

Step 3: Drill a hole

Drill a tiny hole in the middle and deep to fit through the screw head. Then gradually enlarge the opening till the head separates from the bit. 

Gently twist it to remove it from your bit if it sticks. You have found a drill of the required diameter to release that screw shaft.

Step 4: Finish it off

In sheet elements such as a door frame, shaft drilling often involves going through and out of a hole. In the case of bolts, it is usually satisfactory to remove the shaft head. 

You typically have to drill along the entire axis in the wood materials. Sometimes it helps to touch or wipe the dirt.

Buy a cheap drill bit set for your task, resulting in breakage and blunt drill bits. There are no brad point bits for this. Sometimes you can fill the hole with some JB solder so you can use a spare bolt with a similar diameter without loosening it.

Also Read: Best Drill for Mixing Thinset


How to remove a screw with no head?

If you find bare shafts, take them with pliers and twist them. If it is buried, put it under the broken screw. It may lift the top and leave your screw from the bottom. You can then remove the adjusting screw with locking pliers. Also, you can drill a suitable size hole in the head of the screw (or in the shaft if the entire head is missing), then insert the extraction tip and twist it counterclockwise till the screw is removed.

How do I remove a small screw with a broken head?

There are several ways to extract small screws having broken heads. If your screw contains metal, try making a notch in the screw top with a Dremel tool. Also, use lubricating oil and a flathead screwdriver to terminate that screw. If your screw is made of wood, try holding and turning the screw with a diagonal cutter. Drilling is probably the best option. First, use a small bit and then a larger one. You can just stick and paint the hole and close it with a new screw.

How can I drill out a screw with no head?

If it’s a wooden screw, the bit will deviate from the middle of your broken screw when you drill it. Bring a pilot drill in an electric drill to detour this to start penetrating. Then move on to the twist drill to complete the screw drilling. The drill press securely attached to the table with the workpiece can withstand lateral movement. If it’s a metal screw, try an extractor. You need to drill a small hole in the broken screw and use an extractor with a wrench.

Final Verdict

People who work on a renovation or DIY project have applied excessive torque and removed the head of a screw. However, extracting the broken screw is tricky if the construction material is rusted. 

Always remember to sweep and thoroughly clean the area of ​​screw fragments. Knowing how to remove a broken screw without an extractor will make your task hassle-free.

In our guide, we have mentioned some step-by-step guides with different methods. You can try out one if you want. If you are still not satisfied with the answers and need something to know, contact us directly.

Share on:

Samuel H. Murphy is DIY expert and Interior Designer. He is also a part time content writer of Capische. He lives in Warren city, Michigan. He test tools like drill, saw, sander, air compressor etc and helps readers to find out the best tools.

Leave a Comment