Recognition
2012
Top 100 Most Romantic Restaurants in the US – OpenTable Diners' Choice Awards
Award of Excellence – Wine Spectator Magazine
2011
Award of Excellence – Wine Spectator Magazine
Restaurant of the Year – Aipono Awards – Maui No Ka Oi Magazine
#1 Italian Restaurant In Hawaii – Zagat Surveys
Top Fifty Most Romantic Restaurants in America – OpenTable.com
Critic's Choice Ilima Award - Best Neighboring Island Restaurant - Honolulu Star-Advertiser
2010
Award of Excellence – Wine Spectator Magazine
Most Romantic Restaurant – Aipono Awards – Maui No Ka Oi Magazine
2009
Award of Excellence – Wine Spectator Magazine
Most Romantic Restaurant – Aipono Awards – Maui No Ka Oi Magazine
#1 Italian Restaurant In Hawaii – Zagat Surveys
2008
Chef of the Year Brian Etheredge – Aipono Awards – Maui No Ka Oi Magazine
Award of Excellence – Wine Spectator Magazine
Maui's Best Kept Secret - Fodors
Most Romantic Restaurant – Aipono Awards – Maui No Ka Oi Magazine
2007
Award of Excellence – Wine Spectator Magazine
Most Romantic Restaurant – Aipono Awards – Maui No Ka Oi Magazine
2006
Award of Excellence – Wine Spectator Magazine
Best Restaurant of the Year – Maui News
2005
Award of Excellence – Wine Spectator Magazine
2004
Award of Excellence – Wine Spectator Magazine
2001
Judge's Taste Award Winner - Taste of Lahaina